These High Protein Pudding Halloween Dirt Cups are a must try! Made with 3 ingredients for the pudding and topped with crushed cookies and gummies.

1

These dirt cups are the easiest, most delicious Halloween dessert made with a creamy chocolate cottage cheese pudding, crushed chocolate cookies and gummy worms. They’re nostalgic, ridiculously fun to make and secretly packed with protein thanks to the cottage cheese base.

If there is one dessert that immediately takes me back to being a kid, it’s dirt cups. You know the ones: chocolate pudding, crushed chocolate cookies that look like dirt and gummy worms crawling out of the top. They’re a little messy, a little ridiculous and exactly the kind of dessert my kids lose their minds over.

Except, of course, we’re giving the classic dirt cup situation a little Rachel-style upgrade over here.

Instead of using a packaged chocolate pudding mix, we are making the creamiest chocolate pudding using cottage cheese, cacao powder and maple syrup. That’s it! Three ingredients go into the blender and somehow turn into this rich, creamy chocolate pudding that tastes way more decadent than you’d expect.

Then we layer it with crushed double chocolate cookies and gummy worms for the ultimate spooky Halloween treat.

And when I tell you my kids think these are the coolest things ever…

These dirt cups are perfect for Halloween parties, after-school snacks in October, playdates or really any time you want to make dessert a little more fun. Plus, they’re incredibly easy to assemble. There is no baking, no stovetop and barely any prep involved.

2

What are dirt cups?

Traditional dirt cups are a nostalgic dessert made with chocolate pudding, crushed chocolate sandwich cookies and gummy worms. The crushed cookies resemble dirt, hence the name.

They’re typically served in clear cups so you can see all of the layers, which is half the fun.

For this version, we’re swapping the traditional pudding for my chocolate cottage cheese pudding. If you haven’t jumped on the cottage cheese dessert train yet, this is your sign.

Once cottage cheese is blended, the texture completely changes. It becomes smooth, thick and creamy, making it such an easy base for pudding. Add cacao powder and maple syrup and you have a chocolate pudding that takes about two minutes to make.

I love that these feel like a total treat while also having a little extra protein from the cottage cheese. And no, you really don’t taste cottage cheese once everything is blended together.

My kids just know they’re eating chocolate pudding covered in cookies and gummy worms. We can keep the rest between us.

Why you’ll love these healthier dirt cups

First of all, these are just FUN.

I am always looking for festive recipes that don’t require me to spend hours decorating something. I love a themed treat, but I don’t necessarily have the patience to make elaborate cookies or cakes every time there’s a holiday.

These dirt cups give you all of the Halloween energy with almost zero effort.

They’re also made with only six ingredients total, including the toppings. The pudding itself only requires three ingredients.

Everything comes together in a blender, so there is no cooking required. You can make the pudding ahead of time and assemble the cups when you’re ready to serve them.

And they’re super customizable. Use whatever chocolate cookies you love, add as many gummy worms as your heart desires and make the servings as large or small as you want.

You could even set up a little dirt cup bar for a Halloween party and let the kids assemble their own.

Ingredients you need to make dirt cups

Full-fat cottage cheese: This is the base of our chocolate pudding. I definitely recommend using full-fat cottage cheese here because it makes the pudding much richer and creamier. Once blended, you won’t have that traditional cottage cheese texture at all.

Maple syrup: Our sweetener! I love using maple syrup because it blends seamlessly into the cottage cheese and adds the perfect amount of sweetness. You can adjust the amount slightly depending on how sweet you like your chocolate pudding.

Cacao powder: This gives the pudding its rich chocolate flavor. Unsweetened cocoa powder can also work if that is what you have on hand.

Double chocolate cookies: This is our “dirt.” I love using double chocolate cookies because they give the cups that dark, chocolatey crumb that looks like actual dirt. Use your favorite store-bought cookies or homemade ones. Gluten-free cookies work perfectly here too.

Gummy worms: You can’t make dirt cups without the worms! Add a few to each cup so they look like they’re crawling through the cookie crumbs.

How to make chocolate cottage cheese dirt cups

These might be one of the easiest desserts you make all Halloween season.

Start by adding the cottage cheese, maple syrup and cacao powder to a blender.

Blend everything together until completely smooth and creamy. You may need to stop and scrape down the sides depending on your blender. Keep blending until you don’t see any cottage cheese curds remaining. We want this to have a true pudding consistency.

Next, add your chocolate cookies to a large zip-top bag. Seal the bag and crush the cookies into small crumbs. You can use a rolling pin, the bottom of a glass or even your hands.

And now comes the fun part: assembly.

Add some of the crushed chocolate cookies to the bottom of each cup. Spoon the chocolate cottage cheese pudding on top. Add another layer of crushed cookies and finish everything off with gummy worms.

That’s it.

The cookie crumbs look like dirt, the gummy worms make everything delightfully creepy and you have the cutest Halloween dessert with very little actual work.

Can you taste the cottage cheese?

This is probably going to be the first question everyone asks, and I get it.

I personally don’t think these taste like cottage cheese.

The key is blending everything really well. You want to keep the blender going until the cottage cheese is completely smooth and there are no curds left.

Once you add cacao powder and maple syrup, it transforms into this rich chocolate pudding situation. The cottage cheese adds creaminess and gives the dessert more staying power than your average pudding cup.

If your kids are skeptical of cottage cheese, I’d probably just serve them the dirt cups before announcing the secret ingredient. Because once there are chocolate cookie crumbs and gummy worms involved, I have a feeling they won’t be asking too many questions.

How to make these dirt cups gluten-free

These are incredibly easy to make gluten-free.

The chocolate pudding mixture itself is naturally gluten-free, so you just need to use your favorite gluten-free chocolate cookies for the dirt layer.

Double-check your gummy worms as well if you need the entire dessert to be strictly gluten-free, since ingredients and manufacturing processes vary by brand.

Otherwise, the recipe stays exactly the same.

I love recipes like this because you don’t have to make an entirely separate dessert for someone who eats gluten-free. Everyone can eat the same thing.

Tips for making the best dirt cups

Use full-fat cottage cheese if you can. The fat gives the pudding a much richer and creamier texture.

And blend, blend, blend! If you stop too early, you may still have some of the cottage cheese texture. A high-speed blender makes this incredibly easy, but any blender should work with a little patience.

You also want to crush the cookies pretty finely if you want them to really resemble dirt. I like having mostly fine crumbs with a few slightly larger pieces mixed in for texture.

If you’re making these ahead of time, I recommend preparing the pudding and crushed cookies separately. Assemble the cups closer to serving so the cookie crumbs stay crunchy.

5

Can you make dirt cups ahead of time?

Yes!

The chocolate cottage cheese pudding is actually a great make-ahead dessert. Blend it together and store it in an airtight container in the refrigerator until you’re ready to assemble.

You can also crush the cookies ahead of time and keep them in a sealed bag or container at room temperature.

When you’re ready to serve, layer everything into individual cups and add the gummy worms.

If you fully assemble the dirt cups ahead of time, they’ll still taste delicious, but the cookies will soften as they sit in the pudding. Some people actually love that texture, so it really comes down to preference.

A fun Halloween dessert for kids

Halloween food does not need to be complicated.

Give my kids something chocolate with a gummy worm sticking out of it and suddenly I am apparently the most creative mom on the planet.

These dirt cups would be so cute for a classroom party, Halloween playdate, family movie night or Halloween party at home.

You can make them in little clear cups for individual servings or make one big dirt pudding situation in a glass bowl and let everyone scoop their own.

For younger kids, you can also let them assemble the cups themselves. Put out bowls of chocolate pudding, cookie crumbs and gummy worms and let them go to town.

Will your kitchen table be covered in cookie dirt afterward? Probably.

But that’s Halloween with kids, right?

5

The easiest cottage cheese Halloween dessert

I love a recipe that looks impressive to kids but secretly took me about 10 minutes to make.

These chocolate cottage cheese dirt cups are creamy, chocolatey, crunchy and just the right amount of spooky.

You have a three-ingredient chocolate pudding, crushed double chocolate cookies and gummy worms all layered together into the easiest Halloween treat.

And because the base is made with cottage cheese, there’s some protein hiding underneath all of that cookie “dirt,” which I will happily take as a mom win.

Make these for your next Halloween party, serve them as an after-school surprise or add them to your Halloween night spread.

They’re nostalgic, kid-approved and so ridiculously easy.

Basically, my favorite kind of recipe.

Print

High Protein Pudding Halloween Dirt Cups

5 Stars 4 Stars 3 Stars 2 Stars 1 Star

5 from 1 review

These High Protein Pudding Halloween Dirt Cups are a must try! Made with 3 ingredients for the pudding and topped with crushed cookies and gummies.

  • Prep Time: 10 mins
  • Total Time: 10 mins

Yield: 3-4 1x

Ingredients

Scale

Ingredients:

Toppings:

Instructions

  1. Add cottage cheese, maple syrup and cacao powder to a blender or food processor and blend until completely smooth and creamy, scraping down the sides as needed.
  2. Add the chocolate cookies to a large zip-top bag and crush into small crumbs using your hands or a rolling pin.
  3. Add a layer of crushed chocolate cookies to the bottom of small serving cups or jars.
  4. Spoon a layer of the chocolate cottage cheese pudding on top.
  5. Add another generous layer of crushed chocolate cookies to create the “dirt.”
  6. Top each cup with gummy worms and enjoy!
  7. Serve right away or refrigerate until ready to eat.

Notes

*Store in fridge for 5 days

  • Author: Rachel Mansfield